The Yin and Yang of Flawed Heroes

ND Blog Tour - Nations Divided coverThe Yin and Yang of Flawed Heroes 
Guest post by Steve P. Vincent

Superman is boring.

There, I said it. He has too many powers that he didn’t really earn. He fights for nothing against enemies that are well below his weight class. He has no weaknesses, except for a rock. Worst of all, he has no personality, either as Superman or as Clark Kent, who’s possibly the most boring person on Earth. I’ve never been very interested in him as a character.

That’s because the essence of a great story is flawed, complex characters pursuing their goals in a way that creates conflict, with bonus points if it’s set somewhere cool. From Achilles to Indiana Jones to John McClane to Tony Soprano to Omar, characters who are flawed – emotionally, morally, physically or psychologically – are more fun to cheer for.

Flaws help to balance characters out, to give them weaknesses to compensate for their awesome and things to overcome either as the main plot or important side plots. The true test of a champion isn’t simply winning, it’s overcoming obstacles on the way to that triumph.

But there’s also more important reasons to celebrate flawed characters:

–          Flaws create tension. God mode is boring.

–          Flaws help to make things familiar. Nobody likes a boyscout.

–          Flaws make a character relatable. Everyone screws up sometimes.

–          Flaws provide fun ways to learn about a character. Eye patches are cool.

In my own writing, across the three Jack Emery novels – The Foundation, State of Emergency and Nations Divided – I’ve relied heavily on Jack’s flaws. He’s not an action hero, but a journalist who drinks too much, gets himself in too deep, doesn’t really feel safe doing so and yet can’t help himself.

Jack is a a character who I think readers want to cheer for and his inherent flaws also keep the stakes high. When he’s being shot at, he can’t really shoot back and he could die. When he’s being beaten up, it hurts. When he’s unable to solve a problem, he gets frustrated and drinks beer and eats fried chicken. He’s a bit of a jerk.

But he’s also saved the world. He’s overcome the nastiest parts of his drinking problem. He divorced his wife but treats his new partner well. He sees the best in people but often deals with the worst. He’s afraid of danger but doesn’t back down from it. Through his flaws, it is possible to learn more about him and cheer for him to succeed, but never be sure doing so.

This doesn’t mean a hero needs to be a womanising alcoholic who is a bit of a sissy when the fists start flying, It does mean that a few minor flaws are welcome, helping to humanise the character and often combined with a major flaw that impacts the plot becomes the defining struggle in the book. Then there’s the tragic flaws, which usually bring down the hero.

Flaws shouldn’t be limited to heroes, either. Meglomaniac baddies with no real weaknesses who still manage to lose anyway are just as boring as Superman.

But that’s another story. This writer’s flaw is that he’s inherently lazy…

Steve P. Vincent is the author of the Jack Emery series of political thrillers – The Foundation, State of Emergency and Nations Divided. Connect with him on the web, Facebook, Twitter or Goodreads

About the Author:
ND Blog Tour - Author Shot
Steve P. Vincent lives with his wife in a pokey apartment in Melbourne, Australia, where he’s forced to write on the couch in front of an obnoxiously large television.

When he’s not writing, Steve keeps food and flat whites on the table working for the man. He enjoys beer, whisky, sports and dreaming up ever more elaborate conspiracy theories to write about.

He has a Bachelor of Arts (Hons) in Political Science and History. His honors thesis was on the topic of global terrorism. He has traveled extensively through Europe, the United States and Asia.


Twitter: @stevepvincent
Facebook: /stevepvincentwriter



Similar Articles




Recent Book Trailers



Don't Miss

National Book Foundation to Present Lifetime Achievement Award to Karen Tei Yamashita

National Book Foundation to Present Lifetime Achievement Award to Karen Tei Yamashita The National Book Foundation, presenter of the National Book Awards, today announced that...

Ellen DeGeneres’s Picture Book Coming May 2022

Ellen DeGeneres's Picture Book LITTLE ELLEN Coming From RHCB in May 2022 Emmy Award–winning talk show host, comedian, actress, and entertainment pioneer Ellen DeGeneres will publish a...


To help libraries meet increased demand for digital content, OverDrive donated 260 juvenile and young adult titles to more than 21,000 public libraries around the world....

Finalists for 2021 Kirkus Prize Are Revealed

Kirkus announced the 18 finalists in three categories for the annual Kirkus Prize, one of the richest literary awards in the world. Kirkus Press Release: The...


THE WINDSOR METHOD by GUY WINDSOR The secret behind all great artists is how they practice. The Windsor Method: The Principles of Solo Training is the...

HOUSE OF SLAUGHTER #1 Variant Cover by Gabriele Dell’Otto

BOOM! Studios revealed today a super rare variant cover by acclaimed artist Gabriele Dell’Otto (Detective Comics) for HOUSE OF SLAUGHTER #1, the premiere issue of...


THE COMMODORE’S GIFT BY MANDY EVE BARNETT Fighting against society’s feminine expectations, Owena’s excellent strategic and swordsmanship skills come to the fore after an attack...

BOOK REVIEW: “A Time for Mercy” by John Grisham

 “A Time for Mercy” by John Grisham Five years after Jake Brigance defended Carl Lee in “A Time to Kill” and 2 years after Jake...

PODCAST:: Adventure through the Wastelands with Author Jenna Greene on Book Lights

Adventure through the Wastelands with Author Jenna Greene on Book Lights LISTEN HERE! Jenna Greene is an elementary school teacher. When she isn't teaching or writing,...

Hobbit Day and Tolkien Week Sept 19 – 25, 2021

Did you know there was a Hobbit Day and Tolkien Week? Are you a rabid fan of all things J.R.R. Tolkien? The American Tolkien...