Anna Snow Offers A Rebuttal to David J. Schmidt’s Love in the 21st Century

Imagine my surprise when I opened a website and discovered a guest blog post discussing the ramifications of erotic romance on today’s society by a man who had absolutely no idea what he was talking about.  (I sincerely wish someone would create a sarcasm font. It would’ve came in so handy here.)

In order to not leave anything out, I’d like to address his post one comment at a time.

First of all, if you open your email and see an email inviting you to view a rape documentary and the first thing that crosses your mind is how expensive it would be to go see it, there’s more wrong with you than you realize.

Now, let me get something clear. I hated Fifty Shades of Grey. It was poorly written and gave people the absolute wrong idea about what exactly BDSM is, and what it entails. Case in point, the previous guests (David J. Schmidt) post. (You can read to post by following the link).

I also hated Twilight. Again, here was a poorly written book with another bat crap crazy female lead that couldn’t live without her sissy of a boyfriend. Did these books give some women the wrong idea as to how they should behave and what they should be willing to let a man do to them and get away with? Yes.

BUT, this isn’t the case with all erotic romances. If you’d step out from under the Fifty Shades shadow and actually read an erotic romance by an author who knows what they’re doing/talking about, you might be surprised at how enjoyable you find the story.

Let me quote Mr. Schmidt’s post: I recently watched “Double Indemnity”, a film noir from 1944. Sure, the main character is always pulling women around by the upper arm to get them to go along with him, as if they had no sense of agency of their own, or were incapable of responding to a simple, verbal “hey, come over here please”. Sure, the lead male has a habit of fiercely shaking his love interest by the shoulders as a prelude to kissing her.” 

Obviously Mr. Schmidt isn’t familiar with gentlemanly behavior. In times past a man often ushered a woman into or through a room by either grasping her upper arm, elbow, or placing his hand at the small of her back and guiding her, thus preventing her from tripping in her high heels, being bumped into, or knocked over by other people in the room. There was nothing hurtful or violent in the action. As for the “violent” shaking before a passionate kiss, I think whether or not it’s actually violent comes down to who’s viewing it.

Lets move on to Mr. Schmidt’s reference to odd sexual practices. Again, lets quote his post: “I also hold “Fifty Shades” and its kin responsible for my confusion. My misunderstanding of the aforementioned email—and the vagueness of the email’s title itself—are the direct result of these books, as they have normalized imprecise language. More than the bizarre sexual practices, the poor syntax is, perhaps, the most disturbing thing about the whole “Fifty Shades” series.

For a man who’s picture depicts him with long hair holding a beer, Mr. Schmidt seems to be a bit of a prude. Just because you don’t practice or understand a specific sexual behavior, practice or lifestyle doesn’t mean that behavior is odd, wrong, or inappropriate. It just means you don’t understand it and should keep your mouth shut about it until you do. There are several books out there, nothing like Fifty Shades, that can help even the most prudish of people understand these practices.

Let’s talk about men and women wearing bruises with pride. This isn’t a way to brag about violent sex. Those dark marks are a reminder of the passion they shared and experienced with their partner, their consenting partner. A small smile as they catch sight of one means they’re experiencing an abundance of great memories. Great non-violent memories.

As a matter of fact, BDSM, whether practiced lightly or heavily, isn’t violent sex. There’s nothing violent about it, but only someone who understands what exactly BDSM is and entails would understands this. To do so means you have to leave the missionary position and actually open a book. NOT Fifty Shades.

Was Fifty Shades a poorly written book? Absolutely. But that trilogy should not be what causes people to classify all erotic romance as crap.

Erotic romance writers put more thought into their stories than, “Hmm, how kinky can I make this scene?” As a matter of fact, that’s the furthest thing from our minds. Our main concerns are how to entice the reader, make the reader think, make them dream, and take them away from their everyday reality that may not be all that great.

Now, let’s tackle the F-Bomb. Mr. Schmidt says: “Every time Christian Grey says a phrase like “thank f***”—as if F*** were some commonly accepted deity to whom we offer thanks and praise.” 

I don’t think it takes a genius to figure out that not everyone who writes or reads feels comfortable saying “Thank God” every time we want to make praise. Some people don’t believe in God, and others don’t feel comfortable with the word used in certain context, so, this is another one of those attempts to make the book a comfortable read for everyone. Not an attempt to decimate the English language. I actually use the big, bad, F-Bomb quite often.

And last but not least, completely bashing someone’s work in order to pimp your own isn’t the way to gain readers attention or massive sales. Despite how many of us feel about the Fifty Shades Trilogy and the Twilight Saga, these books have legions of fans, all ready to stand at their favorite books defense should the need arise.

Don’t group all erotica and erotic authors together, and don’t judge them by the likes of Fifty Shades and Twilight.

Believe it or not, women are not the weaker sex, and although the above-mentioned book may depict women as weak-willed, weak-minded ninnies, today’s average woman is intelligent enough to realize such. Don’t expect to see women in the fetal position every time to going gets tough. We’re not Bella Swan or the insanely sway-able Anastasia Steele.  

We’re intelligent, strong, and yes, highly sexual creatures. Perhaps were some men to realize this and stop trying to put us in boxes, they’d live happier lives with a very sexual woman, but as I said before, you have to actually leave the missionary position to find out.

About the Author:
Anna Snow began writing more than five years ago, and hasn’t stopped since. She’s been published by several publishers and has been nominated for countless awards. Anna loves life, and can think of nothing she enjoys more than spending time with her family and friends. She loves archery, reading, writing, kitties, spending time outdoors, and did I mention kitties? *big grin*

Before becoming Anna Snow, she released several books spanning all genres under the name, Chastity Bush. Anna also loves to hear from her fans and answers all correspondence she receives.  You can reach her at

(Editor’s Note:  All guest bloggers are given the opportunity to insert links.)



Similar Articles




Recent Book Trailers



Don't Miss

Penguin Random House to Purchase Simon & Schuster

In a just released press release, it has been announced the Penguin Random House Books will purchase the veritable Simon & Schuster Publishing. Here are...

Book Review: A Bride of Convenience

A Bride of Convenience by Jody Hedlund My rating: 4 of 5 stars This is such a heartwarming book. I absolutely love the characters and how...

No Comic-Con, No Problem: Del Rey and Out of Print Team Up to Launch...

In advance of the 30th anniversary of Timothy Zahn’s Heir to the Empire in May 2021, Del Rey and Out of Print have teamed up to celebrate Thrawn like never...

Thankful Thanksgiving Wishes

Reader’s Entertainment Magazine and Radio started over a decade ago. We have won awards both for the magazine and the radio podcast. We’ve featured...

A Light in the Darkness by Rian McMurtry Book Trailer

0 Angela Fujimori enters her sophomore year of high school with a world changed. She apprenticed herself to a necromancer classmate to learn magic and...

There’s a Book for That: Thanksgiving 2020

Tomorrow we celebrate Thanksgiving like no other before it, probably. While the food traditions may be the same, our guests will be fewer as...

Throwback Thursday Book Trailer: New Moon by Rebecca York

0   From March 9th, 2007 Dark secrets and parallel universes bring together a man who is part wolf and a woman who is his lifemate...from another...

New York Public Library Author Talks

We love the New York Public Library! And we love their commitment to books, literacy, authors and community. NYPL offers author videos with some of...

Disney Books: New YA Releases

REBEL ROSE by Emma Theriault  Happily ever after is only the beginning as Belle takes on the responsibility of becoming queen and learns to balance...

Book Review: The Moonlight School by Suzanne Woods Fisher

The Moonlight School by Suzanne Woods Fisher My rating: 5 of 5 stars Wow, I’m at a loss for words with this book. I’m not even...