Google vs Author’s Guild – Book Scanning to Continue

In a reversal of a court order, authors can no longer sue Google as a group. A three judge panel overturned a previous order that had allowed this and other protections to authors in the Google Books Library Project case.

The case was brought in 2005 as Google began scanning millions of books, to date an estimated 20-million books, and offered no compensation to authors or their estates in the case of a deceased author. The Author’s Guild, according to documents, was asking at least $750 per scanned book as payment. Google refused and the litigation was started. Google said the cost was too high and would cost the company “billions” if they were forced to comply.

In their ruling the judges stated: “Putting aside the merits of Google’s claim that plaintiffs are not representative of the certified class — an argument which, in our view, may carry some force — we believe that the resolution of Google’s fair use defense in the first instance will necessarily inform and perhaps moot our analysis of many class certification issues.

The panel also stated, that Judge Denny Chin, who had ruled more favorably toward the authors and whose ruling they overturned had, “prematurely certified a class of authors without first deciding if the “fair use” defense under U.S. copyright law allowed Google to display snippets of books.” Chin had also ruled that, “it would be unfair to force authors to sue individually given the “sweeping and undiscriminating nature of Google’s unauthorized copying.”

No longer can a group of authors sue Google. Any legal suits must be brought individually and handled on a case-by-case basis.

Michael Boni, a lawyer for The Authors Guild said: “We’re obviously disappointed. We’re going to litigate the fair use now, and that is the shooting match.”

You can read more concerning the class action suit by following this link.

The case is Authors Guild Inc et al v. Google Inc, 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 12-3200.

Similar Articles

Comments

FOLLOW US

2,027FansLike
3,238FollowersFollow
10,100SubscribersSubscribe

Recent Book Trailers

Instagram

Advertisment

Don't Miss

A Broken Childhood by Lydia Ola Taiwo – Throwback Thursday

0
Something thoughtful and soulful to remember from 2013. Lydia Ola Taiwo's A Broken Childhood is still available and still emotionally charged. At the age of...

SNEAK PEEK: New Mysteries From Kensington Books

0
Murder Can Haunt Your Handiwork - A Haunted Craft Fair Mystery #3 by Rose Pressey In Rose Pressey's third Haunted Craft Fair Mystery, a Gilded Age ghost...

PODCAST: Talking Fiction Obsessions with Author Mark Leslie on Book Lights

0
Talking Fiction Obsessions with Author Mark Leslie on Book Lights LISTEN HERE!!! Mark Leslie would be the first person to admit he's still afraid of the...

Hourglass Socioeconomics: Principles & Fundamentals by Blaine Stewart

0
Here's our interview with Blaine Stewart on Hourglass Socioeconomics: Principles & Fundamentals. https://youtu.be/ELHangieSL4 We can not sustain a system where a river runs into a wasteland...

There’s a Book for That: Inauguration Day

0
The inauguration of Joe Biden as the 46th President of the United States begins at noon (ET) today, Wednesday, January 20. The inaugural ceremony...

PODCAST: Be an Accessory to Magic with Author Kathrin Hutson

0
Be an Accessory to Magic with Author Kathrin Hutson LISTEN HERE!! International Bestselling Author Kathrin Hutson has been writing Dark Fantasy, Sci-Fi, and LGBTQ Speculative Fiction...

SNEAK PEEK: D (A Tale of Two Worlds): by Michel Faber

0
D (A Tale of Two Worlds): by Michel Faber “Glorious. A story that will be found and enjoyed and dreamed about for years to come.”—Neil...

Actor/Comedian Kevin Hart to Publish Middle-Grade Series with RHCB

0
Comedian, actor, producer, and entrepreneur Kevin Hart will release his debut children’s book, MARCUS MAKES A MOVIE, to be published by Crown Books for Young Readers, an imprint...

SNEAK PEEK: Van der Valk-Love in Amsterdam: by Nicolas Freeling

0
Van der Valk-Love in Amsterdam: by Nicolas Freeling *NOW A LIMITED SERIES ON MASTERPIECE PBS* Meet Van Der Valk, Amsterdam’s best detective, in Nicolas Freeling’s classic...

SNEAK PEEK: Come On In: 15 Stories about Immigration and Finding Home

0
Come On In: 15 Stories about Immigration and Finding Home (Anthology) A timely and illuminating collection of stories featuring teen immigrants, for readers who loved Black...