Anna Snow Replies to David J. Schmidt

Hello lovely ladies and handsome gentlemen.

Thank you for taking the time to read my rebuttal post. Now, before you dig in, I think you should read Mr. David J. Schmidt’s original blog piece located here:

After that, you may understand my first rebuttal a little better.

Now, on to the subject at hand.

It never ceases to amaze me how some people can make themselves into a victim.

A few months ago I wrote a little rebuttal to a piece written by a fellow author, Mr. David J. Schmidt, when he decided to give his opinion on the ramifications of erotic romance on today’s society.

I was upset by his implications that we were somehow deviants if we enjoyed BDSM or anything other than the good ol’ missionary position.

This morning I read his rebuttal to my rebuttal and had to laugh. No, I wasn’t laughing because it was a funny little piece made to make you smile, but because Mr. Schmidt made himself a victim while avoiding the original topic at hand.

“only to find that a vicious rebuttal had been launched against me! I was overcome with a mixture of feelings: surprise, anguish, indignation, and indigestion.”

“(The merciless and calumnious essay can be found here: Now don’t get me wrong, I am always willing to accept peer reviews of my literary opus. As the Book of Proverbs says, “As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens the character of another”. (Prov. 27:17)”

“Firstly and foremostly, I resent the accusation that I “do not know what I am talking about”, quoted here:”

First of all, I didn’t attack Mr. Schmidt. Believe me, if I had, everyone would have known it. When I said he didn’t know what he was talking about, I was referring to the subject of erotica and BDSM, but I guess when he wrote his rebuttal, he decided to leave that part out, as he wouldn’t have appeared as the poor attacked victim.

“I am far from an ignorant, unlettered country swain, Ms. Snow. I will have you know, I hold a Masters of Divinity in Applied Eugenics from the Queen’s University of New Caledonia, and am currently the acting chair of the Phrenology Department of Point Loma Nazarene University. I have been a licensed phrenologist for the past twelve years, and have received stellar reviews from my peers and colleagues. These are hardly the credentials of a person who “has absolutely no idea what he is talking about”!

Secondly and secondofmostly, I must object to the claim that I am a “prude””

Go ahead Mr. Schmidt, wave your education proudly, you should, but your degrees in Phrenology (phre·nol·o·gy the study of the conformation of the skull based on the belief that it is indicative of mental faculties and character) and Eugenics (a science that deals with the improvement (as by control of human mating) of hereditary qualities of a race or breed) doesn’t cover the fact that you really know nothing about erotica and all it entails. You wrote this “poor me” post without confronting the original topic.

“Thirdly and thirdmostly, I wish to present a recontrabuttal against the accusation that I am “unfamiliar with the conduct of a gentleman. I have been on a total of four dates in the course of my life, and am proud to say that I behaved in a singularly cordial fashion on each occasion. As I held the door for my date, invited her to a sumptuous four-course dinner of the Colonel’s Extra Crispy Popcorn Chicken, poured her a champagne flute of Bacardi Breezer, and treated her to a viewing of the art film Kangaroo Jack, I was the very incarnation of chivalry and courtliness. Still believe I don’t know how a gentleman behaves? Just ask the women for whom I singlehandedly paid the bus fare home at 11:30pm on the San Diego Public Transit System!”

I’m not even going to dignify this portion of Mr. Schmidt’s rebuttal with a response as it clearly speaks for itself. Any sane woman or man would see this and run for the hills.

I resent Ms. Snow’s claims that I am ungentlemanly, prudish, and ignorant”

Now THIS cracked me up and I’m laughing even now just rereading it.

Mr. Schmidt, the only one here making you look ignorant, prudish, or ungentlemanly is you not only with this “Poor me. That mean Ms. Snow attacked me,” post, but with your first piece as well.

I think you should stick to your celebrity cameos, answering fan mail, and making appearances on Pat Robertson’s “The 700 Club” (You see, I didn’t list my accomplishments or everyday routines to make my self appear successful) and leave the subject of erotica, its fabulous readers, and writers to those of us who know what it truly means.

Anna Snow


About the Author:

Anna Snow began writing as soon as she could hold a pen and hasn’t stopped since. She’s been published by several publishers and has been nominated for countless awards. Anna loves life, and can think of nothing she enjoys more than spending time with her family and friends. She loves archery, reading, writing, kitties, spending time outdoors, and did I mention kitties? *big grin*

Anna also loves to hear from her fans and answers all correspondence she receives.  You can reach her at:

You can learn more about Anna and her books by visiting her website. Other books by Anna can be found here.

Similar Articles




Recent Book Trailers



Don't Miss

In a 1960s World That Is Changing, a Young Girl Finds Her Place in...

On the cusp of her eleventh birthday, Becky Chalmers is straddling childhood and growing up as she navigates the world of the 1960s in her idyllic...

American Library Association Releases Preliminary Data on 2022 Book Bans

Total book challenges in 2022 set to exceed 2021 record Eight months into 2022, the number of attempts to ban or restrict library resources in...

GUEST POST: Fall for These Apple Turnovers By Valerie Burns

Autumn is almost here and what better way to get into the season all about falling leaves, apple picking, and cozying up than with...

Penguin Random House Partners With TikTok to Transform Book Discovery

With more than 75 billion views and counting, #BookTok is one of TikTok’s most popular hashtags, building a vibrant, global community of people who...

George M. Johnson Named Honorary Chair of Banned Books Week

The Banned Books Week Coalition is proud to announce that George M. Johnson has been named Honorary Chair for Banned Books Week 2022. The...

Death in the Everglades Tells Real-Life Stories of Murders, Accidents, Airline Disasters, Bus Crashes,...

Death in the Everglades, the seventh book by Randi Minetor in the nonfiction series about real people who die in national parks, dives deep into the...


iscover Skull and Bones: Savage Storm: an all new series from Dark Horse and Ubisoft Dark Horse Comics is proud to team up with Ubisoft...

Talking With A GEM OF TRUTH Author Kimberley Woodhouse

Welcome Kimberley!! Your books are filled with just the right amount of adventure, intrigue, and romance. What was the inspiration for your new novel A...


Sometimes high school drama feels like the end of the world…even during the real end of the world. From Dark Horse Comics, Acclaimed creator Curt...